Skip to main content

After Tiller


DOCUMENTARY PROJECT REFLECTION- AFTER TILLER


I chose to do my Guided Reflection on After Tiller. Dr. George Tiller is one of four doctors in the world that perform abortions during the third- trimester of a pregnancy in 2009. This is during a time when bombings are known to happen at any abortion location at any time. Society is very out spoken on their views and the Dr. had received an insurmountable amount of death threats. He has gone through many lows in like due to the nature of his work. He has not only been divorced because of his job, but also feels alienated for the rest of the world.

I felt an overwhelming sense of sadness, when I hear the secretary trying to explain how the procedure will work to a potential client over the phone. She is very detailed in her description and make sure the client knows that this is a labor and delivery, not a surgery. I can’t help thinking,” how does she feel? She looks like she may be under a lot of stress. She says, “You need to be psychologically prepared for that.”

What really surprised me is finding out that this is a three-day process and once started, it cannot be stopped.  It also surprised me the stories about why people wanted to choose this method of abortion. Hearing one mother explain how she found out about a condition after being twenty-five weeks and the issues that could arise. Hearing that the child that you carry is not a “viable child”, could be extremely overwhelming and harmful to her psychological and mental strength.

It shocks me that these doctors who take an oath to save lives, are able to find peace in ending lives. With so much opposition that they face on a day-to-day basis, it make me wonder, how do they have to strength to fight every single day?  The emails that they receive from the initial questions to potential clients, is mind-boggling. It makes me wonder if Dr. Tiller has a shrink on hand. How are these doctors able to deal with this amount of stress?

It’s really perplexing to comprehend how one part of the world feel that this type of abortion is an abomination and others think this is a “gift from God.” When you love your unborn child so much that you are burdened with the thought of bringing them into this world to only be able to live in a vegetative state, what are your options?

The questions that still remain is how accurate are these screening, that say these unborn fetus are going to have some disease. I feel I am able to question such decisions as I was told that one of my own children would have down-syndrome 23 chromosomes, and it may be best for me to have a Dilation and curettage also known as DNC at the hospital as I already had one child with disabilities. Well needless to say, I decided to  have my son and absolutely nothing is wrong with him. He is the smartest kid I know. In sixth grade, he had already read at a twelfth grade level. 


Not that I have any good feelings about the video that I have watched, but I will say that after learning about partial-birth abortion, I think this is the lessor of two evils. I do commend the doctors who stand up for what they believe in, even if my beliefs are not the same. I know that it takes great courage and strength to “go against the grain.” However, Susan Phillips once said, “Anything that’s worth having is worth fighting for.”

Comments

  1. First, I'm so glad to hear that your choices turned out so beautifully for you and your family! Second, I commend your ability to stay with such a difficult film and the difficult questions it raises. You seem genuinely willing to expand beyond your comforts when you ask, "When you love your unborn child so much that you are burdened with the thought of bringing them into this world to only be able to live in a vegetative state, what are your options?" You show valuable comprehension here, and even gesture at analysis, which is fine for this venue.

    You note that you see the life-saving oath as being at odds with performing the services the doctors provide, but in some ways, they do save lives. It's so vexing and complicated.

    Thank you for your thoughtful reflection.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As I read your comment, I am excited to see that I can look beyond the lens that I had at the start of your class. While I know I have much work to do when it comes to "technical writing," I also know the mind has to go to places it hasn't before to be able to "think outside the box."

      I dream to one day be able to use words the way that you do, so thought provoking, intentional and often times perplexing (which is a good thing.) When you wrote, "but in some ways, they do save lives." this made me think, yes, they do.

      Thanks for not being the "typical" teacher. I know that I am on my way to being a better writer because of your course.

      Delete
  2. You honor me, brilliant Natasha! I'm glad you see more of the range of TW now!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Redesign

User Interface and User Experience Space Assessment This document outlines our assessments for a proposed redesign of Yen Ching, a local Chinese restaurant located at 810 W. Lincoln Highway in DeKalb, IL. In 1986, the Yin’s started their first restaurant on Fourth Street in DeKalb, IL. The business was strong enough for the family business to move to a larger location in 1990.  The current location is close to the campus of Northern Illinois University (NIU) and they were able to sustain business due to the new location and their authentic Chinese food. Online reviews from Trip Advisor 4/5 (24 reviews) rated #15/85 restaurants in DeKalb and Yelp 4.5/5 (60 reviews) helped share insight to the this long-standing local restaurant. With only 3 total one-star and 46 five-star ratings between the two sites, the restaurant is well-received and supported by both locals and visitors to the area. The food quality is described as fresh, fantastic and a Chinese favorite but with eac...

BOX-LOGIC

BOX-LOGIC Geoffrey Sirc begins his essay "Box-Logic" by expressing his frustrations with the typical learning in writing while society is ever-changing. He says, “The rapid advance of technology has meant a pedagogical dilemma for me: just what do I do in the classroom, what do I teach?”(113) He battles with the traditional  way of writing and creating some other style of writing that the world seems to going towards. He uses several pieces of works by different writers and poets to argue his points. Geoffrey has some questions that he has to ask himself and anyone who is in the teaching profession. Essentially he is saying, what do you do, when everything you have been taught seems to be changing? He looks at a writing from Marcel Duchamp’s Green Box (1934) to help him find some unconventional ways to view writing. From taking notes, to rearranging post-its to playing with the way you present the words, in an art form . He also looks at Joseph Cornell, Walter Benj...

Negatives of Ridesharing

Negatives of Ridesharing While there are many advantages of Ridesharing it is important to know there are many disadvantages as well. First we have to get some of society to overlook the rules that they have been taught their entire lives, “don’t get into a car with a stranger.” Well that is exactly what ridesharing is. You do not know the person personally that will be picking you up, so this leads to credibility. One of the cons of ridesharings is that there are so many companies out in the market and it is difficult for the end user to differentiate the major difference amongst the leaders of market. After all, when you get into your car you want to make it to your planned destination. There are been a lot of negative press about ridesharing from parton's being kidnapped from Lyft drivers to a lyft drive kinnapped, zip-tied and rapped a customer. While these cases may seem extreme it is important to know that they are accurate and true. In 2016 there was an incident where a...